Latest News
My latest ramblings.
Enjoy! I definitely got important things to say
My latest ramblings.
Enjoy! I definitely got important things to say

Genre: Spy + Action
Platform: Netflix
Time: 6 x 48 minutes average
Director: Julian Farino. Kieron Hawkes
Cast: Keira Knightley (Helen Webb). Ben Whishaw (Sam Young). Sarah Lancashire (Elizabeth Reed). Andrew Buchan (Prime Minister Wallace Webb, Helen’s husband). Ambika Mod (Laila).
Plot: Helen Webb’s husband Wallace is a shoo in for the British PM’s post. Her handler Reed is clear that the long-term strategy of the Black Doves has finally succeeded and asks Helen to be fully prepared to share the PM’s secrets. And then Reed vanishes. Helen’s assassin friend Sam is caught by the police after an assassination. In the police station, he is visited by a mysterious man named Patrick who promises him freedom – in exchange for four targeted killings. After Reed’s disappearance, a Mr. Conteh asks Helen to continue with her task. Into this mix enters a Russian former KGB officer turned oligarch who has his own agenda. ….
I was absolutely riveted for the first three episodes. Then after E 4,5,6 I felt cheated. Not that its not good or even crap. Many of the scenes are written well and some are even great. But the sum total of all these parts seems a very disjointed effort. There is more emphasis on gunplay and blood spattering violence. The poster of the series is the clear giveaway – everyone is toting a gun . That makes it clear what will follow in the name of spying – shootouts, shootouts and more shootouts.
The Tarantino style over the top violence and (supposedly) witty dialogues are now found wanting . This is just bigger, better and trying to out-Bond, the Bond and MI movies with the level of high speed chases, large explosions, enough ammo expended to make WW2 look like a summer holiday – in short, this is a serious case of style over content. The wafer thin plot ? Ah – lets come to that. Now Helen is the British PM’s wife and therein hangs a tale. Before reading any further if you want to check out what was my take on Season 1 , check out the link https://rammesh.co.in/2024/12/08/878/.
The tropes are already well known for those who watched Season 1, but there are many illogical things that defy explanation. Mainly, the PM’s wife can walk in and out of 10 Downing without a Personal security officer and / or no questions asked, no one tracking her movements and no one any wiser. She carries out hit jobs and returns and no one is any wiser. Sam, the assassin with a conscience, is still his same. The White lesbian pair of assassins are back and now joined by another South Asian assassin Laila Joshi (!!) whose approach to spying is very American – shoot everything that moves. The overall violence level doesn’t affect Helen and she seems to be actually enjoying it. And why is all this onscreen mayhem happening? Because Reed was involved in something very nasty, in the bad old days of the Cold War in 1988, in East Berlin – one year before the fall of the Wall.
The overall emphasis seems to be less on the cheeky lines, which is left to the lesbian assassins, while the hyper violence is left to Joshi, Helen, Sam and assorted men in black, shooting it out with each other. All the anonymous opponents of the quartet die like flies while they remain unscratched. There is less of spying and more of violent gunplay of the automatic weapons, grenade explosions type, combined with the traditional high speed car chases. There are enough holes in the story that make you think “where on earth is the logic of this? where is this going?” and so on.
The way the last episode ends, it’s clear that they have left room for a possible S3 – that is if Sam doesn’t end up becoming a monk in the very monastery where he carried out a hit, and Helen doesn’t end up becoming a schizophrenic because of her role as the PM’s wife and a Black Dove, and confessing her duel roles to her psychiatrist cum marriage counsellor.
The overall feeling is like reading a comic book; if that is the intention then it has succeeded admirably.
Summary : Keep your brains outside if you want to enjoy this. I couldn’t!
Script – 2 out of 5
Story – 2 out of 5
Direction – 3 out of 5
Photography – 3 out of 5
Total – 2.5 out of 5
Clickable links in red
Sometime in the mid-2000s, due to my deep interest in history and military history, I came across many hitherto unknown information that challenged the conventional (Western) military wisdom. With internet opening up in India and visiting many websites, I had many instances of new insights to old events. Many earlier accounts were now seen to be semi propaganda while others had to be revised due to new facts being revealed almost on a daily basis. One of them even questioned the supposedly ‘ superior competence’ of Western Allied generals who had access to the ULTRA secrets, the breaking of German ciphers and yet they were outfought and out maneuvered by the Germans in many engagements . I always wondered why and how the Germans fought so stubbornly, against overwhelming Allied superiority while at times the Allies appeared to be floundering in the dark.
On the Eastern Front, the earlier constant myth was that the Germans faced “human waves” of Russian soldiers and Russian generals were supposedly no good. This was the biggest lie as I understood that many Russian generals were smart and used the SAME GERMAN TACTICS against the Germans – use massive force in rapid pincer movements and crush the centre of the pincer, as happened at Stalingrad (and which accounted for the early lightning German victories from June to December 1941).
Yet another “Eastern Front story” was about a supposed ‘death match’ between Nazis and their captives. Depending on who was talking, the captives were hard core dedicated Soviet Communists, Ukrainian Nationalists, Jewish prisoners and everything else in between. The common element in all these stories was:
Thankfully Wikipedia has an excellent page that demolishes all the myths, with multiple citations and references.
Short version – most of the deaths were myths and the Nazis didn’t shoot any of the players. Since the matches happened in Kiev between a regular Ukrainian team and the Nazis, post war Soviet propaganda played it up to put a pro Soviet spin on the events. Some players were prosecuted as Nazi collaborators AFTER the war by the Soviets , and hence the Ukrainian version that they were all shot dead. Some survived the war and one of them even emigrated to Canada. Four ‘slave’ players were killed during WW2 for other reasons and that too long after the so called ‘death match’. Any which way you look at it , the Nazis were and are the super villains (and they will continue to be so).
As with most such stories, the enduring wisdom seems to conform to that old newspaper saying; “when the legend is larger than the truth; print the legend”. Thus, there are multiple stories and films of “slaves beat the masters’ versions, all of which are cited in the Wikipedia page. I will talk about the two films that I have seen and my conclusions on the same

Genre: WW2 escape film + sports film
Platform: Amazon Prime US (UNAVAILABLE in India)
Time: 1 Hour 50 minutes
Director: John Huston
Cast: Michael Caine (Captain John Colby). Sylvester Stallone (Robert Hatch). Pelé (Corporal Luis Fernandez). Max von Sydow (Major Karl von Steiner).
Plot: British Captain Colby wants to escape from a POW camp along with his fellow prisoners as part of an overall plan. Canadian Robert Hatch wants to go it alone. Camp commandant Steiner has a brilliant idea of a match between the POWs and the Germans to boost the morale. Colby insists on having to pick his men from various camps and also increase their rations. Hatch escapes from the camp and meets the Resistance leaders in Paris who ask him to be deliberately captured by the Nazis so that they can plan a mass escape of all POWs and the players ….
I remember that the film was promoted internationally as one where many top football players from various countries acted as POWs and that was supposedly the main attraction. Pele, a black Brazilian, was explained as being from the West Indies, which was under British rule. The story, as with all such ‘sports’ movies, was predictable in that you know very well that the ‘home team’ would win.
I also remember that Time magazine (or was that Newsweek) had commented on the film thus (from my memory): We don’t know what is more painful to watch. Caine trying to play football or Pele trying to act. I suppose that sums up the story perfectly. Here’s a small You Tube clip which is both silly and funny at the same – Pele explaining to Michael Caine how to beat the Germans
Curiously, it was filmed in then Communist Hungary. This was because it was supposedly based on the 1962 Hungarian film Két félidő a pokolban (Two half-times in Hell), which is a Hungarian version / reworking of the legend of the Death Match, but with Hungarian POWs instead of Ukrainian players.
Unfortunately, the film is unavailable on any Indian channels and is on Amazon Prime US.
Script – 3 out of 5
Story – 3 out of 5
Direction – 4 out of 5
Photography – 3 out of 5
Total – 3.3 out of 5

Genre: WW2 escape film + sports film
Platform: Amazon Prime India – rent
Time: 1 Hour 50 minutes
Director: Dominik and Jakov Sedlar
Cast: Franco Nero (old Branko). Viktor Kulhanek (young Branko). Andrej Dojkić (Laszlo Horvath). Caspar Phillipson (Colonel Franz).
Plot: In the current, an old Branko watches his grandson play football and lose to the opposing team. Branko takes his dejected grandson to a park and tells him that only as a team can they win football and narrates his life and death experience as a young boy during WW2. With Hungary occupied by Nazi Germany in March 1944, sizeable German troops are present in Hungary. The Hungarians don’t have much choice in what they say or do. Colonel Franz has an idea of a football match between his POWs and a Nazi team, on April 20, 1944 – Adolf Hitler’s Birthday, since he has spotted Laszlo Horvath, a famous football player, in his POW camp. Laszlo negotiates with the Colonel for better food and treatment, afternoons off for practice and so on. A young Branko who was being mistreated by another German officer is rescued by Laszlo and brought under his care and even made part of the team. The death match begins and at half time with the Hungarians leading 1-0 against the Nazis, Franz gives an ultimatum,. Lose the match and live. Win and you die. …
This is yet another variation of the same 1962 Hungarian film. The film was made in English, in Croatia and with a mix of Croat, Hollywood and actors from other countries. This is a far better film than Escape to Victory, and is engaging, once Laszlo starts training the team. Since there are less ‘stars’ to cope with, the characters are given more importance.
The only grating thing is the constant cutting between the present / old Branko and the past with young Branko watching the events unfold in front of his eyes. Laszlo’s final order to “hide and live no matter what happens in the second half of the match” is how only Branko survives and narrates his story to his grandson.
The production design is also good and though limited to the camp, the tattered dresses of the POWs contrast the fresh ones of their Hungarian oppressors and their Nazi master. The final shots of the ‘Death Match’ has some limited CGI which is not all that great. The Match itself is a foregone conclusion with the story sticking to the legend. As I said earl;ier, the Nazis will always make great supervillains. Here, it makes a very engaging film. Anyway – didn’t the film declare that it was “Based on true events” in the beginning? 😊
Script – 4 out of 5
Story – 4 out of 5
Direction – 4 out of 5
Photography – 4 out of 5
Total – 4 out of 5

Genre: Road Movie / Road comedy
Platform: You Tube Free
Time: 2 hours 35 minutes
Story, Screenplay, Director: Vijay Anand
Cast: Dev Anand (Madan). Raksha (Kalpana Karthik). Jeevan (Surjit). Madan Puri (Radheshyam “Radhey”). Shashikala (Neeta). Krishan Dhawan (Kuldeep). Lalita Pawar (Kuldeep’s mother).
Plot: Totally broke and thrown out of his rented home, Madan learns that he is heir to a fortune of 11 lakhs left by his late uncle in Mahabaleshwar. En route, he encounters a runaway woman Raksha, who initially dresses up as a male Sardar Nihal Singh. Soon the cat is out of the bag and a romance develops. Madan reaches Bombay and informs his friend Radhey about both the fortune and his new found woman in his life. Radhey promises to help. Madan and Raksha pretend to be a married couple to stay at Mahabaleshwar and to find out about the uncle’s mysterious death…
Twenty-three-year-old Vijay Anand wrote the story, screenplay and directed the film. Modern viewers may scream about ‘nepo brothers’ and similar stuff but in this case Vijay Anand’s deft and firm touch in all departments was clearly visible. Goldie as Vijay Anand was popularly known, really had a golden touch when it came to the box office and this was his first collaboration with big brother and producer, Dev Anand. The pair reached its peak with the stylish 1967 thriller Jewel Thief but that’s for another day and time.
Nau Do Gyarah can be easily said to be Hindi / Indian cinema’s first ever ‘road movie’ and a very loose adaptation of It happened one night (1934), the only commonality being that the lead female character is a runaway heiress. It happened one night was remade at least three times in Hindi Cinema as Solva Saal, Chori Chori and Dil hai ke maanta nahi, the last being the most ‘true’ to the original, right down to scenes being almost copy-pasted.
As we all know, a road movie is where two characters, usually men of opposite temperaments, go or are forced to share a car / bus on a journey. If it’s a man and a woman, typically romance follows. Usually, the lead male and female actor essay the lead characters, making it easy for the audience to identify with the lead pair as they embark on a journey. If it is two men on a journey, either they will bond as friends or in some extreme cases, end up as antagonists, leading to violent climactic scenes.
A cursory look at the outdoor makes it clear that some scenes were definitely shot outdoors in Delhi, Bombay and Mahabaleshwar. This is one of the few films where Dev Anand, in keeping with the character, doesn’t keep changing his clothes from scene to scene. His acting has also a light comic, almost self-deprecatory touch as befitting a character who is broke and penniless, yet defiant to ask for help as in the scene where ‘Sardar Nihal Singh” offers to pay for the petrol for his onward journey to Bombay.
The romantic development naturally follows after the initial fights and the usual haughty acts of a rich haughty woman who has escaped her home from a marriage against her will since the groom Surjit was demanding more money, moments before the marriage. By the long arm of coincidence, Jasjit turns up at Mahabaleshwar with a girlfriend Neeta, who is also enticing Kuldeep with her feminine charm.
A Navketan film without music would be an anomaly. Navketan’s “House Composer” S.D.Burman gives an overall lightweight touch to the proceedings as befitting a romantic comedy cum road movie. Most of the songs have become classics barring the ‘club’ numbers and the unique climatic song with an integrated fight sequence. Since its one of my favorite Dev Anand films and favorite SD Burman albums, lets look at the songs and the order in which they appear in the film, for which SD Burman’s favorite lyricist Majrooh Sultanpuri does immense justice as per the song situation. (Both Burman and Majrooh shared the same date of birth, October 1)
4, 6,7,8 were not numbers that had lots of airplay while the other songs four songs were super hits and could be heard in almost all ‘retro’ radio programs on AIR and Radio Ceylon.
Its also worth mentioning that the choreography was by Zohra Sehgal. The same Zohra Sehgal whom most late 20th and 21st century audiences know as the loveable and or cranky granny.
Overall, the songs, the story and the screenplay are so deftly woven that we fail to appreciate the superb craftsman that was Goldie who integrated everything into a film that can be classified as India’s first ever road movie. Dev Anand and his wife Kalpana Kartik, in her last onscreen appearance, also show some lovely onscreen chemistry, befitting the film’s overall lightweight breezy structure. For its time, it may have been a risk for such a unique theme, but it proved to be a box office hit
The film is free on You Tube
https://youtu.be/sHqlMGEkU40?t=1
Script – 5 out of 5
Story – 5 out of 5
Music – 4 out of 5
Direction – 5 out of 5
Photography – 4 out of 5
Total – 4.6 out of 5
Clickable links are in red

Genre: Spy Film
Platform: Amazon Prime – BBC Player
Time: 3 hours – 2 x 1.5 hour mini series
Director: Edward Hall
Cast: Michelle Dockery (Ruth Gilmartin). Charlotte Rampling (Sally Gilmartin). Hayley Atwell (Eva Delectorskaya). Rufus Sewell (Lucas Romer). Michael Gambon (Lord Romer). Michael Peter Willis (Jochen).
Plot: In the early 1970s, Ruth Gilmartin is visiting her mother with her son Jochen. Her mother Sally is behaving in increasingly suspicious and erratic ways , peering at the surrounding countryside through binoculars, looking for strangers and telling Ruth that ‘they’ are watching her. When a concerned Ruth asks what is going on, Sally gives her a set of typed pages that talks about the life of Eva Delectorskaya . Ruth thinks that her mother is joking when Sally says that she adopted the name and identity Sally Gilmartin, after coming to England during WW2 and she is really the Eva in the typed pages. Ruth reads with increasing astonishment about how Eva was contacted by Lucas Romer, supposedly belonging to a news syndicate but actually running some kind of secret information network into which she is soon inducted, resulting in a series of daring escapades during WW2….
Structurally, the mini series flits back and forth between the current where Ruth gets increasingly drawn into Sally’s world. In the past we see what Eva goes through as a trainee, and then as an agent. If I say anything about the plot it would be a series of spoilers. So let me focus on some of the clever stuff in the film that is based on real incidents.
Some of the early disasters of SIS/MI6 , and other true life incidents, are cleverly woven into the story. Especially the “Venlo incident” where the resident MI6 officers in Amsterdam were lured to a border post at Venlo and kidnapped by German SD agents who bundled them into a car and simply drove over the border into Germany (Holland was neutral in 1939 and it/ Western Europe had not been invaded by Nazis). Here the incident occurs at a town named ‘Preslo’ , near the border with Nazi Germany (very clever ) .
Lucas and Eva become lovers and she is sent to America in early 1940. Romer sets up a “security office” in New York and this clearly a mirror of the real life BSC – British Security Coordination , which was also based in New York. BSC was set up to “coordinate” activities with the FBI , who were overall in charge of all security activities, there being no external intelligence organization in the US at that time. As part of this security activities, Eva is even tasked to sleep with one of Roosevelt’s aides , so that he can be blackmailed and thus pressurized into getting the US on the British side.
In yet another meeting, she sees a nameless man present at a meeting and listening intently to everything she says but some days later the man is dead by suicide. He is identified as a Soviet defector Nekich. This mirrors Walter Krivitsky, one of the earliest Russian defectors and who wrote a book In Stalin’s Secret Service aka I Was Stalin’s agent. Krivitsky was found dead mysteriously in a hotel – just like Nekich in the film.
Such real-life incidents are peppered through the movie.
The rest of the story is somewhat predictable as she sees that her colleagues in New York are mysteriously dying/ killed and there are enemy agents on the loose in New Mexico whom she is supposed to deal with alone. But who are the people who want to kill Eva? The enemy agents? or someone else? Someone close to home?
However, the overall atmosphere including the production design of offices of those times, costumes, cars and so on. This part is exceptional and is often intercut with the “current” happenings in the 1970s as Ruth is being pressurised by Special Branch , as her German lover is supposedly a member of the infamous Baader Meinhof terrorist group. It is at this time that Ruth believes that her mother was correct and there is some kind of coverup, all the way to the highest levels in the government.
The film is based on writer William Boyd’s novel of the same name which also follows a similar structure in flitting between the past and the present. The performances are superb. The basic premise of a mole inside our organization, is as old as spy fiction, but it is done in an engaging way so much that you want to see “where will this go”, “what will happen to Eva” and so on. Since this is a mini movie of one and half hour each, the two mini movies are a worthy binge watch (which is how I did it).
Script – 5 out of 5
Story – 4 out of 5
Direction – 4 out of 5
Photography – 4 out of 5
Production Design – 5 out of 5
Total – 4.4 out of 5

Genre: Documentary – The British and India
Platform: Amazon Prime Rent
Time: 2 hours
Director: Sanjivan Lal
Cast: William Dalrymple. Shashi Tharoor. Ishtiaq Ahmed. M. Rajivlochan. C. Uday Bhaskar. Allister Hinds. Tom Tomlinson
Narrator and Anchor: Boman Irani.
Plot: The 300 years of British presence in India from 1609 to 1947; from East India Company to Lord Mountbatten.
In his novel The Secret Pilgrim (1993), spy novelist John le Carre writes about how British behaved perfidiously, and that too repeatedly against trusting allies. In this case, the narrator of the story, Ned, talks about how Poles placed their trust on the British who proceeded to gayly abandon the Poles, once in 1939 against the Germans, and within six years in 1945, against the Soviet Union. The hero Ned concludes thus:
“Our repeated betrayals of their country have always seemed to me so disgraceful that if I were Polish, I would spit on every passing British shadow, whether I had suffered under the Nazis or the Russians, the British in their time having abandoned the poor Poles to both”.
I had similar feelings while watching this documentary – of spitting at every passing British shadow.
Anger aside , the history though appalling, is deeply interesting. What started as a private enterprise by a trading company, soon became in a hundred years, “The Jewel in the Crown” of the British Empire, thanks to the East India Company and then the British Crown merrily looting India in ever more innovative ways. The history of loot and deceit is told in a matter-of-fact way by British historians like Dalrymple, Hinds, Tomlinson etc all of whom are very clear that the British took much more from India than gave to it. Shashi Tharoor in his inimitable way also adds to the overall history with an Indian perspective – how many famines were deliberately created by the British ; the 1800s alone accounted for more deaths than the 1.5 million estimated deaths of the Bengal famine. Tharoor is also clear that there has been a lot of myth making of British benevolence and points this out from time to time. Other Indian historians present more evidence of how the British proceeded to destroy India , in the name of commerce, buying Indian clothes cheaply and selling British produce in much higher prices. An amazing added information is how Indian ship building was destroyed steadily over the years as Indian wooden ships lasted much longer compared to the British wooden ships, due to the much superior Indian craftsmanship and which was steadily destroyed by the British.
An interesting aside is that the East India Company was strictly business oriented and didn’t give too much thought to converting Indians into Christianity. That followed much later as the Missionaries went about their job of converting “heathens” into Christians. The early British were more practical – they took Indian wives, had children out of them, wore local dresses and ate Indian food. There is collateral evidence for these practices in the books Curry(2005) and The Hungry Empire (2017), both by British writer Lizzie Collingham , about the British hunger for spices , that ultimately led to Empire and the modern British obsession with “curry” and how the British increasingly adopted local cuisine and some cultural practices, such as multiple servants and wives.
Graphs, charts, contemporary paintings, historical photos, newsreels are interspersed with the dry commentary by anchor Boman Irani. Interestingly , clips from various feature films are inserted to prove a point.
Eg – The British stationed troops in multiple kingdoms – paid for by the Rajas of these kingdoms. This is proven with a clip from the film Lagaan (2001) where Captain Russel announces that taxes have to raised for “your protection” , gesturing at the King. These practices more or less bankrupted India. All these may be well known but still this is a comprehensive lesson in the overall “Empire experience’. A clip from Shatranj ke Khiladi (1977) is shown to prove how Awadh was annexed by the British while another clip from Ghare Bhaire (1984) discusses the Partition of Bengal.
The freedom movement also gets its share. The documentary correctly points out the political hara-kiri that the Congress committed by resigning unilaterally in protest against Lord Linlithgow’s declaration of war. The wrong timing of the 1942 Quit India movement, combined with the wholesale arrest of the Congress, paved the way for Muslim League, which had actually been in the doldrums earlier, and this is also pointed out in a dry manner.
This documentary has less to do with the freedom movement and more to do with the overall 300+ year British rule in India and how their rule ultimately proved divisive, since an economically and morally bankrupt “Great” Britain abandoned India and the Parthian shot of a divided India. I have absolutely no problem in recommending this superb documentary narrated and anchored by Boman Irani.
This is two hours well spent; and perhaps some time for self-reflection.
Total – 5 out of 5
Hi Rammesh,
Another superb review, by someone whom I regard as a history-teacher… or at least history-whisperer :)
—
Books which should be required reading on the subject:
‘Inglorious Empire’ and ‘An Era of Darkness’. Both by Shashi Tharoor.
And
‘Churchill’s Secret War: The British Empire and the Ravaging of India during World War II’, by Madhusree Mukerji.
—
The other day, I accidentally fell across ‘The Journal of Historical Geography’, and an article on the subject. Will send it to you offline… but… one point:
“Employing a novel systems approach to analyse historical causality, this study shows how volcanism, climate and society – especially the ruling British East India Company – contributed to the Madras (1832—1833) and Agra (1836—1838) famines”.
Yes, volcanos.
Thanks,
Robin
Hi Robin
History whisperer. I rather like that.
The documentary is excellent and calls a spade a spade.
Both the Tharoor and Mukherji book are among my TBR pile :(
KVR
KVR

Genre: Human Drama
Platform: Free on You Tube with English subtitles
Time: 1 hour 50 minutes
Director: Satyajit Ray
Cast: Soumitra Chatterjee (Apurba “Apu” Kumar Roy). Sharmila Tagore (Aparna Roy, Apu’s wife). Swapan Mukherjee (Pulu, Apu’s friend). Dhiren Ghosh (Apu’s landlord). Dhiresh Majumdar (Sasinarayan, Aparna’s father). Alok Chakravarty (Kajal Roy, Apu and Aparna’s son).
Plot: Apu quits college in Inter and wishes to find a job. He and his friend Pulu go to Pulu’s village to attend his cousin Aparna’s wedding but Apu ends up getting to Aparna, since the groom turns out to be mentally unstable. Apu brings Aparna to Calcutta and she is appalled at his existence in a single room atop a tenement. Soon she adjusts and they find married bliss in their simple existence where she manages the home and he earns money by giving tuitions. Aparna goes back to her native village and dies at childbirth…
Spoiler Alert:
Let me start with the film’s last scene / ending; working backwards, (hopefully) the essence of this human story becomes clearer.
Apu’s estranged 5 year old son Kajal: Tumi Kaun (who are you)?
Apu: Aami tomar bandhu (I am your friend)
Life has come full circle for Apu. Hope. to Confidence. to Love. to Anger and Despair. And once again Hope.
From being an orphan, to a student, to a married man who loses his wife at childbirth and finally becoming a friend to his five-year-old son who is running wild, (since the child lacks any kind of authority figure to ‘control’ him), Apu has undergone the full life cycle, while still in his 20s.
At the film’s beginning, Apu sets out to get a job. His college professor wishes that he continues his studies but Apu is clear that lack of money prevents him from continuing his science education. On a journey to his friend Pulu’s native town Khulna, Pulu reads Apu’s novel and urges him to get it published but fate has other plans in the shape of Pulu’s young teenage cousin Aparna, played with incredible absolute confidence by a then 15-year-old Sharmila Tagore, who Apu is forced to marry out of a sense of saving the girl’s honor and future.
Losing her to the rigors of childbirth. Losing interest in life. Working in a remote mine and sending money to his father-in- law to take care of Kajal. Apu’s overall depression and anger is brought out well in these scenes. He is bitter that life has dealt a bad hand to him . So much that he even doesn’t want anything to do with his son.
Once again it is Pulu’s intervention that proves critical. Pulu brought him to the marriage and Aparna. It is Pulu again who traces the child Kajal and the father Apu, and brings them together. Pulu’s job is over. Will Kajal and Apu live as father and son? The answer is provided by Apu himself to Kajal ; aami tomar bandhu.
In my view this is an ideal conclusion to the story which is actually from the second half of the novel Aparajito. The full circle of life that started with Apu’s birth and his journey till date is known to us . Aparna’s death acts as one more among the many blows that life has dealt him. Yet he comes out of it and despite not knowing what the future holds, he moves on with his ‘bandhu’. As to what Apu and his “bandhu’ will do in the future and what life holds for them is left to our imagination.
Lyrical is the word that frequently comes to my mind while watching the film. The pace is even and the third film of the trilogy shows Ray , the master observer of human emotions, in complete command of the medium. Be it a small river in rural Bengal or a dank tenement near a railway yard, the images that leap out of the screen onto us show the realities of life as seen by Apu (and by us). Subrata Mitra’s cinematography again shows the contrast between the peaceful rural areas and Apu’s somewhat harried life in his one room rooftop tenement that is open to the elements. The film also began Ray’s long association with Soumitra Chatterjee who remained his preferred lead actor well into the 1980s, acting in 14 of Ray’s films, in varying roles.
As the end titles appear, we wish that there had been more about Kajal and his bandhu and we could have known more about them and what happened to them. This is easily the most perfect film of the trilogy and a classic by any definition.
The film is free on You Tube
Script – 5 out of 5
Story – 5 out of 5
Direction – 5 out of 5
Photography – 5 out of 5
Total – 5 out of 5
